Toasted Sandwich (Egg and Cheese)

Indeed, every morning will be good with a filling, yummy, and satisfying toasted sandwich!

In fact, the toasted sandwich filling combines the milky delight of cheese and the incredible flavor and quality of eggs. Inside, it’s decadent, soft, and flavorful; on the outside, it’s crisp, golden brown, and flaky.

Your whole family will surely love it, especially the kids. It’s an easy and quick toaster recipe that you can cook in just ten minutes. Everyone will have something fun, delicious, and pleasant to look forward to for breakfast.

All you need is your handy sandwich toaster for a hassle-free and hearty breakfast for everyone at home. Once you taste it, you’ll realize why you should include it in your favorite sandwich recipes!

How to Make Toasted Sandwich

You will love the toast sandwich if you love bread and eggs in the morning. Not only does it come with bread and eggs, but there’s also a fantastic layer of cheese and butter to make it even more heavenly.

Turn your toaster on to cook the Toasted Sandwich for breakfast!

Ingredients

What do you need to cook the best Toasted Sandwich?

Bread

A lot of us love bread for breakfast, don’t we?

Whether you cook it or not, there are so many ways to prepare bread in the morning. It goes with plenty of food options in the morning, like vegetables, meat, fruits, and sometimes even fish.

You also can use any filling or spread to give it your favorite flavors and for a new sandwich flavor every time. It also comes in vegan, gluten-free, and even keto versions, making it suitable for any diet.

In this recipe, the bread will have the perfect balance of moisture and crispness for a delightful sandwich. I usually use homemade bread, but Food and Wine also suggests using Pullman and sourdough.

According to Grain Foods Foundation, eating bread is a good way to boost fiber intake, increase energy, and improve metabolism. With a healthy filling, you can certainly make bread healthier too!

You will never run out of bread recipes to try. I enjoy using bread for Bread Pizza, Breakfast Sandwich, and French Toast! What’s your favorite way to use bread?

Egg

Do you like eggs for breakfast?

Let’s mix things up while you usually use eggs to fill the bread. Instead of using the egg as a filling, let the bread absorb it for better flavor and texture! In fact, eggs can give the sandwich the perfect golden brown finish.

Once you season the egg, it will be tastier with savory, pungent, and peppery flavors. It will also give the sandwich a flaky and crusty quality. Hence, you can trust that the eggs will be great for flavor, texture, and health.

The Keck Medicine of USC mentioned that eggs could benefit your heart, brain function, eyes, energy, and digestion. Isn’t it amazing how eggs can do wonders for your health and appetite?

If you love eggs for breakfast, then here are more egg recipes you might enjoy:

• Egg and Yam Frittata
• Noodles and Egg Stir Fry
• Fried Eggs
• Egg Omelet Toast
• Egg Mayo Sandwich

Mozzarella cheese

What’s missing from the Toasted Sandwich? Maybe it needs some mozzarella cheese!

Never skip the cheese. It will give the sandwich a smooth and luscious quality. The salty and milky flavor of the mozzarella cheese will surely make the sandwich better. Once the cheese melts into the bread, it will become irresistibly delicious.

Just imagine pulling the sandwich apart and seeing the perfectly melted cheese inside. The rich texture of the cheese can certainly make you feel like you’re having gourmet food.

An article by Cheese Grotto mentioned that other cheese options for sandwiches include cheddar, raclette, gouda, pepperjack, and brie. No matter what happens, be sure to add the cheese, alright?

Butter

It won’t be a Toasted Sandwich recipe without butter.

Toasting the sandwich in butter will give the dish a slightly sweet and creamy flavor. It will also make the bread crispy for a real “toasted” effect from the flavor, texture, and color.

Moreover, the butter prevents the bread from becoming dry, ensuring a moist and soft texture. The aroma of the butter also makes the bread more appetizing. Nothing makes bread better than some butter.

Seasoning

Improve any sandwich recipe with seasonings.

The Toasted Sandwich will definitely taste better with the right herbs and spices. I suggest using garlic powder, onion powder, all-purpose seasoning, and mixed herbs. in this recipe.

You can also use other seasonings to bring out the desired flavors. Remember to use just the right amount of seasoning to give the sandwich a pleasing flavor all throughout.

I’m sure that from the ingredients alone, you’ll be able to tell you’re in for a delightful treat! This dish is definitely something to look forward to!

Directions

How easy and simple is it to make a toast sandwich?

1. Use a buttering knife to spread butter on one side of the bread.
2. In a bowl, mix the eggs with garlic powder, onion powder, all-purpose seasoning, and mixed herbs with a whisk.
3. Grease the sandwich toaster with butter.
4. Brush the egg wash on the other side of the bread.
5. Place the bread on the toaster with the egg-washed side down.
6. Use a spoon to spread the egg mixture on the buttered side. 
7. Then, sprinkle the mozzarella cheese on top.
8. Drizzle some of the egg wash with the cheese.
9. Place the top bread with the buttered side down.
10. Brush the edges of the bread with the egg wash. 
11. Let the dish cook for about ten minutes or until done.
12. Take them out with tongs, let them cool, and serve!

This Cheesy Egg Toasted Sandwich has a lot in store for you from the inside out! It’s the perfect dish to cook on a busy day to get a sumptuous meal!

Tips

Homemade Bread

For a healthier bread alternative, make your own at home!

1. Mix strong bread flour, powdered milk, granulated sugar, salt, nutmeg, and yeast in a bowl.
2. Gradually add the butter as it kneads. 
3. Once the dough is ready, section it into three parts.
4. Mold each dough into a cylindrical shape.
5. Then, arrange them on a greased loaf pan.
6. Let it rise for at least 45 minutes.
7. Bake it for 18 minutes at 150°C in the oven. 

This Homemade Bread recipe makes soft, flavorful, and decadent bread that’s perfect for breakfast and snacks! 

Toasted Sandwich Variations

How can you make Toasted Sandwich so much more interesting?

With this recipe’s ingredients, you can make the sandwich differently. For instance, you can replace the bread with buns and add mayonnaise to make an Egg Mayo Sandwich. It’s also creamy and soft inside!

Instead, cook an Egg Omelette Toast on a dish loaded with eggs. Add bell peppers, tomatoes, onions, and scotch bonnet to make an Omelette Sandwich.

Also, try this Pizza Bread recipe to taste hotdogs and add some meaty goodness. Try any filling combination you want to see which one you like best; every day can be a new Toasted Sandwich Day!

Pan-Fried Toasted Sandwich

Instead of cooking the sandwich in a toaster, you can cook it in a frying pan. Set the heat to medium and cook each side for about six minutes or until you’re content with the doneness. 

Recommended Tools

• Sandwich toaster: Cook the toasted sandwich in the sandwich toaster. 
• Buttering knife: Smear the butter on the bread with a knife.
• Whisk: Make the egg mixture with a whisk.
• Glass bowl: Mix the ingredients for the egg wash in a bowl.
• Pastry brush: Brush the toasted sandwich and the bread with a silicon brush.
• Tongs: Take the bread out of the heat with tongs.
• Spoon: Add the egg mixture to the bread with a spoon.

This post contains affiliate links, which means I earn commission income from qualifying purchases at no extra cost to you. Please read the full disclosure for more information.

Visit my shop for more products.

How to Serve Toasted Sandwich

Always start your day with a good meal that will satisfy your appetite and cravings!!

The Toasted Sandwich will certainly make an awesome breakfast dish for the family. It’s a filling morning meal that will pack everyone with energy, especially the kids. The sandwich will also be a great on-the-go dish for a busy day.

You can also serve it as snacks to kids and adults to give them a fun time. In fact, it can even be one of the best dishes for celebrations, weekends, and occasions. You can serve this in the morning with a glass of:

• Peanut Butter Banana Milkshake
• Chocolate Almond Milk
• Iced Tea
• Strawberry Banana Milkshake
• Fruit Smoothie
• Pineapple Juice

For side dishes, you may want to consider:

• Overnight Oats
• Plantain Porridge
• Granola
• Fried Eggs
• Fruit Salad

Storage Tips

• At room temperature: According to Prevention, sandwiches are best eaten within two hours at room temperature. 

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a toasted sandwich?

A toasted sandwich uses bread with filling inside, and it’s cooked or toasted until it’s crispy and flaky on the outside. You can cook it in a toaster or a pan to make it a “toasted” sandwich.

What is another name for toasted sandwiches?

Sometimes, toasted sandwiches are also called “grilled cheese sandwiches”. It’s because they’re usually filled with cheese and cooked until golden brown and crispy on the outside.

What is grilled vs toasted sandwich?

From their names alone, grilled sandwiches are a type of sandwich that you usually cook in a griller. On the other hand, toasted sandwiches are toasted in a toaster or pan over a stove.

What is the best way to toast a sandwich?

There are plenty of ways to toast sandwiches. For instance, you can cook them in a sandwich toaster, a non-stick pan, or even an air fryer. I suggest cooking a sandwich in a toaster to get the perfect doneness inside and out.